Tuesday, July 21, 2020
Motorcycle Manufacturers Say Plastic Shield is Unsafe, May Void Warranty
Talk about being stuck between a rock and a hard place, or in this case, between a plastic pillion. The country’s largest association of motorcycle manufacturers—Motorcycle Development Program Participants Association, Inc. (MDPPA) has bashed the government’s plan to require the installation of a physical barrier between riders as a method to prevent the spread of COVID-19.
MDPPA, comprised of the big four Japanese brands: Honda, Kawasaki, Suzuki, and Yamaha has issued a statement calling it unnecessary, a safety hazard, and can possibly void the warranty of a brand-new motorcycle.
The government, particularly the Inter-agency Task Force on Emerging Infectious Diseases (IATF) has approved the design, and will be required for all motorcycle back riders. They will start to impose a hefty fine for anyone caught without the barrier starting Sunday, July 26.
Read the full statement below (emphasis ours):
As more businesses return to operations amidst the rising cases of COVID-19 infections in the country, the streets are again being filled with daily commuters shuffling between home and workplace.
However, riding the public transportation these days has been a major struggle because public vehicles are only allowed by the government to take limited passengers as occupants are advised to practice physical distancing. It is for this reason that the Inter-agency Task Force on Emerging Infectious Diseases (IATF) had earlier banned motorcycle back-riding during the pandemic. Yet, to supplement the limited capacity of public transportation, the IATF has recently allowed couples who live in the same residence to ride together, provided that a separator or shield will be placed between rider and pillion. The IATF is considering different designs for the said separator and one that was approved was a design submitted by Bohol Provincial Governor Arthur Yap. Gov. Yap’s pillion shield design uses a clear acrylic barrier held by a steel frame, which will be attached to the passenger foot pegs.
The Motorcycle Development Program Participants Association Inc. (MDPPA) affirms that all motorcycle models from member brands (Honda, Kawasaki, Suzuki and Yamaha) undergo years of careful planning, design and development carried out by teams of engineers to ensure the utmost safety of each unit. Any additional fixture, such as the one proposed by Gov. Yap, will negatively affect stability and handling of a motorcycle, thus, inevitably compromising safety of its occupants. The proposed pillion shield will create significant wind resistance when the motorcycle is in motion. Not only does it drastically reduce aerodynamic efficiency, it also makes it easier for crosswinds to throw the motorcycle off-balance even when running at low speeds.
Motorcycle safety instructors advise riders to break-free from the motorcycle in the event of a crash to avoid being carried by the momentum of the vehicle. Having a barrier behind the rider makes it difficult to do so as it could keep him pinned on his seat as the motorcycle slides out of control. Moreover, portions of the steel frame of the pillion shield could accidentally break-off and cause additional, possibly fatal injury to both rider and passenger.
Fitting a pillion shield of this sort to any type of motorcycle is a possible violation of the Land Transportation Office’s (LTO) modification regulations. The same shall be a breach of the warranty agreement between the motorcycle owner and the manufacturer.
Finally, there is no scientific data that could support claims that installing a pillion shield will help prevent the spread of COVID-19 from rider to passenger. This being the case, the risks outweigh the perceived benefits.
It is, therefore, the position of the MDPPA that in the interest of safety, no additional fixtures or modifications should be done on the motorcycle without the approval of the LTO and the manufacturer. It is also the organization’s opinion that the wearing of at least half face helmet with closed face shield, more so together with face mask or balaclava, is already an excellent measure in preventing infection.
The motorcycle riding gear commonly worn by a rider also doubles as a personal protective equipment (PPE), like those used by medical professionals. As far as COVID-19 infection prevention is concerned, a motorcycle rider’s situation is arguably much better than those sitting inside an enclosed vehicle breathing recirculated air.